"...hanging on for dear life. It didn’t finish with the vigor..."  There were only 3 winches that finished so of course it would get 3rd.  They should have added a second day of testing.  

I have a friend who had his T-Max implode.  It was a real mess inside.  Luckily, it was free.  He replaced it with a Warn.
The rope slipping out of the retainer clip shouldn't mean much as long as there are a couple layers on the spool.  it it was a cable it probably would have finished.  Well, if it didn't implode.  

  Still it looks like it was the only one to use a rode.  I would have liked to seem them all use a cable.
It's interesting that they DNF'ed the Ramsey with only a blown solenoid.  Could have been a mfg issue on the solenoid and not really an issue with the mechanical parts of the winch itself.
Superwinch could have done better if they chose a winch form their Husky line instead of the EPi line.  The Husky's are pretty robust with their worm gear drivetrain.
Still, it's an interesting test.  I would have chosen the Warn to win also.  Most of my friends run Warns, even that Moz guy has one.  Warns have proven themselves time after time.