I had to cut the fenders because I was getting into them. They looked like dog pooh after a few trees (glad I am not in Texas anymore). I went with the BDS 3.5 lift springs and the 5/8 inch boomerangs from M.O.R.E. That is a 35 in my pic...
That CJ has some mad flex to it for being SUA!
Are you keeping your shackles greased? Are they "over torqued"? Check the spring hanger too. Have your springs had a chance to break in? ie, have you lifted the jeep recently? Springs need some break in time. The track bar could be limiting your down travel. Have you installed a longer or adjustable track bar? Not to hash this over too much, I ditched mine. That is not a recommendation so much as a statement of what action I took. That was the only major difference that stood out to me in pics you posted. CJ's didn't have them, YJ's did.