Well if you still have the bolt-on flange at the end of teh down-pipe then you can use a bolt-on cat like the Magna Flow.  It's a good hi-performance cat that weighs less then the OEM.  It's only $90.  For teh exhaust, I went with Borla.  They have an awesome warranty and back it 100%.  Banks or Magna Flow would be my second choice.  It shouldn't be loud but have a nice rumble.