Still, if for example, somebody was buying my jeep, they'd for sure get a ride that's been used on a few trails and has a dent or two and plenty of under-body scrapes. But they'd also be getting a ride that's been fairly meticulously maintained for the last 11 years.
But I have heard of guys who thrash rides and don't take maintenance seriously and will just lay all that up on the next owner.
Exactly my point... You don't know which one you are getting when you buy. If I ever decide to buy mine, the buyer will also be getting a good deal; I do wheel my rig in mud, but I have the underbody proffessionally cleaned after each ride with pressure washers and also use a graphite lubricant to avoid rust. Also, all parts and mods are made thinking of longevity, as I drive this thing 600 miles between Panama and Costa Rica every 3 months. But then again, once in Panama, it gets driven twice a month (maybe 10 miles each time) and that's it... And all maintenance is done with more regularity than what the manual says (every time I cross a river, for example, I replace the diff oil, and that happens a couple of times a year).
But some fellow club members are not so careful, so if you were to buy their rigs, your luck would not be as good...
So like you said, it's a toss up. You can get with a rig that's worth A LOT more than if you were to buy the parts (God knows my rig would NEVER sell for what I have put into it!), but you can also easily get a Lemon. I think an important question is always to ask WHY the seller is selling the rig...
Felipe