I ended up coming to my senses and I think I'll go with Wheel Vintiques which sells vintage style wheels which look a lot like the old kelsey hayes wheels that just about every OEM used back in the day. I'm torn between 7" or 8" and 15" vs 16" but I'm not in a hurry.
The problem with 16" is that the tires 255/85R16's only come as a E Class tire. And 8" is a little wide for a 10.5" tire. I'm currently running 33x10.5R15's so I might judt stick with them. The other thing is 7" come with 4.5" BS which is alright.
That's 1" less them my stock TJ 15x7's which is probably good since I've got the turn stops shimmed out with two washers. The 8" only come in 4" BS which adds another .5" to the mix. I don't want to have to install larger flares as I like the stock YJ flares though I think both would fit under the flare.
The 8" would also allow me to go to a wider tire but I don't think that will happen. Also, 16" would allow me to use a larger brake package. I'm not in a hurry with this either since I would also have to plan out what axles I want to go with them. No point in swapping wheels just to do it again when I change axles later on down the road.
Here's the 7" with 4.5" BS
You can see how much deeper the 8" with 4" looks.