I believe I repaired the vacuum leak at the throttle shaft! One night I couldn't sleep and decided to inspect the throttle shaft bearings a little closer. It turns out that each throttle shaft bearing has a square-cut seal on each side of them (4 total). The seals on my 4.0 TB were in horrible condition so I picked them out with an awl and measured them with a caliper. The dimentions I got from the measurements were:
- 1/2" O.D.
- .060" thickness (like measuring the thickness of a washer)
- 3/8" I.D. approximate (my seals were worn badly, that's why it's approximate)
** The throttle shaft diameter was measured at 0.372" which is very close to
3/8".
The next day, I went to Ace Hardware and got 4 o-rings of similar dimension. I cleaned the bearings with carb cleaner, lubed up the o-rings and slipped them right in. Then I lubed the bearings with high temp grease. To be sure the throttle shaft wouldn't cut my new o-rings when sliding it in, I wire-wheeled the shaft and sanded any sharp points along it with my Dremel.
I put everything back together and installed the 4.0 TB, started up the Jeep and performed the leak check around the throttle shaft (sprayed carb cleaner). No rise in rpms! I'm not sure if this is a permanent fix due to using o-rings instead of square cut seals. Also the material of the o-rings is not positively known, so they may break down sooner or later. If that happens, I'll be sure to get Buta-N or nitrile o-rings which resist petroleum products very well.
The o-ring size I used was 1/2" O.D. X 3/8" I.D. X 1/16" thick. The square cut seal's thickness is 0.060" which is 0.0025" thinner than the o-ring, but I don't really think that matters too much. Sorry about the novel, I just wanted to explain in detail in case someone else runs into this problem in the future. It may not be a permanant fix, but it should last for a while.