To save a little cash, I have been using 87 octane gas. Recently, I started using 91 (93/94 where I'm from back east) Octane which is "Supreme" at $2.80+ for self serve in So Cal.
I figured the jeep 4 and 6 cyls are designed to run on regular 87 and that running higher octane fuel means you are essentially throwing your money away. But, for whatever reason (ECU Timing advance?), my 4 does seem to drive a bit better on 91 (89, mid-grade doesn't seem to perform any better than regular 87 on mine). Anyway, my Jeep 4 cyl Revs better, has better low end torque, generally more fun around town. Heck, enough to where I may not bother with any more power upgrades unless I do a lift, rear axle swap, lockers & 33" tire set up vs my current stock & 30's setup. Of course, if I did a major suspension/axle change, then I'd probably get serious and swap or supercharge.
You guys are probably wisely running regular. But, if you are drivng an upgraded 4 (perhaps with an open K&N sucking more warm engine air that can cause the ECU to retard timing) you may find it worthwhile to go with your area's high-octane fuel (91-94+ depending on altitude and other factors). It's f#$%ing expensive, but it's made me a little more at peace with the current mild performance upgrade setup on my YJ 4 cyl.