I averaged about 17 on stock-ish 235's and nothing more than a K&N Filter. Went to 33's, it dropped down to about 13-14 city, and maybe 15 highway. 4:88's helped some, but it was still maybe 16 max. Added the 4.0 TB and it gained me a bit more. After swapping to my current 35" MT/R's my mileage went up again, which surprised me a bit. At this point in time I'm getting about 16-17 in town, and 17+ highway.
aw12345 do you have the 2.4 or 2.5? You must have the NSG-307 (I think that's the name?) 6 speed? Only reason I ask is because I've read that swapping it to an older 2.5 like mine will be a PITA, and I'd LOVE to have a 6 speed. Jeep must have made it an option with the 2.4 I take it? I'd love to try and swap one in eventually, I think it'd make the 4 cyl even more driveable up and over the mountains.