Thought about it some more. Check your local Craigslist. That's usually the best place to find a used winch. Since it's local, you won't have to pay for shipping.
Another winch, I'd probably look for is a Tabor 9000. These are built by Warn for the Export market. The only difference is the lower HP motors (which all older Warns used) black paint and some plastic parts that replace the metal ones in no-stress areas like handles and such. So it's a Warn without the Warn price. Be aware that there are a lot of no-name winches on the market as well. Smittybilt, Bulldog, T-Rex, etc... These are made in China so quality can be hit and miss. Since you seem to have a healthy budget, I wouldn't bother with any of those. Stick with Warn. They have an awesome Customer Service as well.