I dunno, you might want to think bigger picture. I started off with 30/9.5 BFG at's, Then went to 30/10.5 BFG MTs, now I am at 32 MTR's! To make matters worse I want to regear and get a locker and go with 33's! Its addicting. Where do you want your jeep to be in a year?
The BFG AT's were really good on the street. In mud the turned into racing slicks.
The BFG MT's were decent on the street. Too big for a stock TJ for offroading. They would rub at when I flexed up my Jeep. But for street driving and moderate wheeling they should be fine. A small cheap lift would take car e of that.
I then bought a rancho lift and bought 32inch Goodyear MTRs, they have been really good both on and off road. I can't seem to wear them out! When I do get the money and they wear out, I will buy MTR's again. My gearing isn't low enough with the 32's and my jeep can barely get ouf of its own way, even with all the basic performance mods.
Id recommend the MTR's, There is my 2 cents...
TC