any e-fan would work as long as you can bolt the shroud nicely to the side brackets on the radiator and if it covers the radiator core - measure your core and then measure the e-fan shroud you find, cant remember exactly but it is something like 18x20 or close, measure yours to make sure. Can't help you with the ones you mentioned as i have no idea what dimensions they are, i have a radiator in the garage i can measure if you want.