Mileage went down to just over 11. The only thing I changed was swapping the soft top for a bikini and taking the K&N/Rockit city air intake tube off and swapping in a OE TJ intake box.
How much areo loss is there by going from a soft top to a bikini?
A lot. There is too much turbulence with no top or bikini top on. Air gets sucked back into the Jeep from behind, air getting sucked in from the sides, etc... I noticed a difference in mileage when I went from Soft top to a hard top even though the hardtop adds weight. The hardtop has a slicker surface so there is less for teh wind to grab, not to mention it's 2" shorter then the softtop. The softtop inflates at higher speeds which also increases it's size. The flapping doesn't help either. BUT this is at higher speeds. Aerodynamics come into play at speeds higher then 35MPH. At 55MPH it's not too bad, even 60MPH but start pushing it to 70 or higher and you'll start to hit the proverbial brick wall.
I've mentioned this before but I played around, removing a bunch of weight and noticed no difference at highway speeds in mileage. I removed my rear bumper, rear seat, spare, spare mount, passenger side mirror, winch, winch plate, aux lights etc and noticed very little is any difference at highway speeds. I did notice it was quicker from a stand still.
Also when I was playing around with the intake and exhaust, I noticed I have more torque with the stock air box and my Borla. I was running a K&N open element and I was able to REV more freely but there wasn't as much torque at the low or mid. I had more HP at the top end though. I also noticed when I punched a 2" tear in my exhaust right after teh muffler, I had less torque but had more HP at the top end. It was enough to feel the difference.