5" is a lot of height for a short-arm type lift, will cause lots of problems offroad and on. Like mentioned above, use as little lift as possible to clear your desired tire height. A 3" or 3.5" kit works well with a 1" body lift.
You can get a good SYE for as low as $180, and I recommend getting a used TJ or XJ front driveshaft and having it shortened for use in the rear with the SYE. Save you a lot of $$.