Also, would my 5 inches of lift look too funny with 31's?
I currently have 31's on with 4" of lift... This is how it looks like:
I think your would look similar with 31's (one inch is not that noticeable i think).
With the gearing, 31's might be a little too low for a daily driver. I'd look into 33x10.r15's though.
+1; with 4.88, 33" should get you to about stock level, and the 10.5 will be lighter than the 12.5 (not to mention that they will create less drag at highway speed because they are thinner).
Personally, I am thinking about getting 33's and droppin in the 4.88's, which should improve my mileage a little (I am currently getting 15 mpg with 4.10; I am hoping to bring it up to about 17~18 mpg).
Felipe